In this #ContentChat community conversation we explore ways and reasons why to break free from these molds. Don’t worry, it’s not as scary as you may think.
As we gather for #ContentChat please introduce yourself, and share if you have participated in a meme or trend-jacking on behalf of a brand.
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
Q1: To meme, or not to meme, that is the question! Should brands participate in popular memes? What are the advantages of doing so, versus the pitfalls?
Mirroring our poll results, the community says that it depends on the situation.
Q1: To meme, or not to meme, that is the question! Should brands participate in popular memes? What are the advantages of doing so, versus the pitfalls? #ContentChat
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
It’s important for brands to understand the full context of a meme or event before jumping on the bandwagon, and it needs to make sense for their audience.
A1a: everyone hates the “It depends” answer, but, truly, it depends! On the #B2B side of things, if you jump on a trend, or participate in a meme, you have to be certain it’s going to resonate with your audience and not be seen as frivolous. #contentchat
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
A1c: If you are marketing a hip, with-it, consumer brand OTOH, not participating can be seen as off-brand. It comes down to your audience. Are they in on the joke and making up their own versions of it? Then it may pay to play. #ContentChat
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
A1: It definitely depends. It’s important to know the full context of the meme or event, so you don’t step in it. And you shouldn’t shoehorn it in. Only do it if you have an idea for doing so that makes sense #ContentChat
— Kristen Hicks (@atxcopywriter) May 20, 2019
A1: It truly depends on the audience. If a brand’s target audience is younger and in tune with popular memes, it makes sense to take advantage of that. If a brand’s audience is not up to date with the latest memes, it wouldn’t resonate with them. #ContentChat
— Nex Gen Dynamics (@nexgendynamics) May 20, 2019
And please, please, make sure you know what the slang means for anything you say, or you end up with McD’s saying that you’d have sex with a cheeseburger. #contentchat
— John Cloonan (@johncloonan) May 20, 2019
A1b. One advantage of meme-jacking is that the brand can prove that it’s part of popular culture. You’d expect people to be talking about #GoT today, and brands might take this opportunity to show they’re participating in the same conversations as their audience. #ContentChat https://t.co/2y9XIcdmIo
— David Simanoff (@dsimanoff) May 20, 2019
It’s not only about whether your audience will “get” it, it’s also about whether or not you alienate a portion of your audience with what you post.
Exactly!
It can alienate a certain section of
your audience too! You have to think about all of your stakeholders! #contentchat— Bentley University (@bentleyu) May 20, 2019
For instance, if you run with a meme popular in the 18-24 year old demographic, and your audience is younger GenX, it may not be so smart. But if your audience is Baby Boomer parents, they might laugh and think of their grandkids. #ContentChat
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
A1d: I’ve also seen a number of brands jump on viral video memes, thinking it’s a good way to make their workplace seem cool from a recruitment standpoint. As someone who hates forced group fun, it has the opposite effect on me. #ContentChat
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
If something doesn’t work for an external audience, it may work for your internal audience.
A1: I personally love to use memes for internal communications. Then I don’t have to worry about copyrights, people look at the content, cause it’s funny, and the tone is more personal. #ContentChat https://t.co/HQiy0f9kkf
— Jen Brass Jenkins (@chrliechaz) May 20, 2019
A1b – I think memes/gifs are more appropriate for employee engagement and company culture (again, IF it fits your brand)—not for product marketing, sales pitching, etc. Let’s agree to avoid the “trying too hard” look… #ContentChat
— Elizabeth M (@LizAshleyMedia) May 20, 2019
In either case, your brand identity should also be a guiding factor. If your brand is more conservative or business-focused, memes may not be the way to go.
A1b: When you are marketing a subscription to an expensive, multi-year SaaS product, for example, you risk some prospects take your meme-jacking as an indication you aren’t very “serious”, which can translate to less trustworthy. #ContentChat
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
A1 : It totally depends on the brand—if the brand has a sense of humor, wants be “humanize” itself, etc, go for the memes and gifs. If you’re very corporate, conservative, buttoned up–memes may not be for you. Each brand personality is different #ContentChat https://t.co/1399zCaxCQ
— Elizabeth M (@LizAshleyMedia) May 20, 2019
A1. I think the answer really depends on the brand’s personality and the audience’s expectations. I’d be shocked if Apple did the same thing as Moon Pie. #ContentChat https://t.co/2y9XIcdmIo
— David Simanoff (@dsimanoff) May 20, 2019
A1: My answer is going to be probably the same for all of these – It Depends. If it makes no sense as it relates to who you’re marketing to or your brand image, don’t try to participate in a meme. If it lines up and you’ve got the wit to engage, then go for it. #ContentChat
— Derek Pillie (@derekpillie) May 20, 2019
A1: I think it really depends on the brand and the situation. it can be fun if that humor is part of their brand voice or something they do a little more frequently than a brand that jumped on a meme out of the blue. #ContentChat
— Bernie Fussenegger #Digital360Chat (@B2the7) May 20, 2019
Always run a legal check before engaging in anything pop culture. If you have experience with this, comment below or pitch Erika to be a guest in a future Content Chat.
Totally agree. And Q: What are the legalities behind picking up images online and using them? What about embedding memes in our content? #ContentChat https://t.co/lfiVDhp1q5
— Jen Brass Jenkins (@chrliechaz) May 20, 2019
I always wonder about this too! I’m not sure I’ve seen a good answer, so I mostly steer clear from using memes and gifs in my content #ContentChat
— Kristen Hicks (@atxcopywriter) May 20, 2019
When it works, though, the reward could be worth the risk.
A1
Should brands participate in
popular memes?It depends
on their:-audience
-message
-tone
-industry
-personality
-voice
-goal
-purpose
-strategyPros:
-authenticity
-humanizes brand
-relatableCons:
hurt trust
hurt repDepends on how
it aligns w/ your brand#contentchat— Bentley University (@bentleyu) May 20, 2019
A1
More pros:
-build points of connection
-deepen relationships
-increase visibility + reach
-help support voice/tone
-illustrate brand personality
-generate buzz
-bridge a gap between you + target
-memorable/unique way to share info#contentchat— Bentley University (@bentleyu) May 20, 2019
Q2: What are some examples of brands doing a good job with hopping onto popular culture trends or memes without sacrificing their brand?
Some of the best cases blend pop culture with proprietary or industry-relevant data, like with Sprinklr’s Game of Thrones content.
I may be jumping on a future question, but @Sprinklr‘s GoT content is a good example of a way to do it that makes sense—since they’re sharing data from their product that is interesting and relevant to fans #contentchat https://t.co/fxnSRfxI94
— Kristen Hicks (@atxcopywriter) May 20, 2019
Since I already answered (with this example: https://t.co/VUG4civF4B), I’ll elaborate on why it works: it provides interesting information about the conversations ppl are having, while demonstrating a particular value of the product at the same time #contentchat
— Kristen Hicks (@atxcopywriter) May 20, 2019
This is a SMART example. When you can use your product and your unique data to comment on a pop culture event it’s such a concrete way to market and reach your audience. #ContentChat https://t.co/roMzkabbFi
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
Food and beverage brands like Pepsi have successfully integrated pop culture into their brand over time, but be careful to appropriately research any endorsements.
A2: @pepsi Did a great job referencing pop culture in their ad featuring @iamcardib #OKRRR Also @tacobell. They know how to engage with their younger audience. #contentchat https://t.co/9IB5vGUVSS
— Elizabeth M (@LizAshleyMedia) May 20, 2019
That Okrrr catchphrase originated with @LaganjaEstranja. Cardi and Pepsi should credit where it’s due! #ContentChat pic.twitter.com/3hGjCvJmis
— David Simanoff (@dsimanoff) May 20, 2019
A2. I think some restaurants are doing a good job with this. Wendy’s and Burger King come to mind. #ContentChat https://t.co/gnx3y2Gx1K
— David Simanoff (@dsimanoff) May 20, 2019
A2: Bud Light as there was a natural subject matter tie-in and all eyes were on them at super bowl time: https://t.co/hgvdZUpjWG #contentchat
— Jennifer L. Dawson (@JLDContentQueen) May 20, 2019
A2: @MoonPie team are champs at fitting into pop culture trends. Not sure I’ve gotten a Moon Pie because of it, but I’ve enjoyed their efforts. #ContentChat
— Alan Fleming (@alan_fleming) May 20, 2019
Entertainment brands are in a strong position to leverage pop culture. Depending on the company, meme use or jumping on a bandwagon could double as promotion.
A2: .@netflix does a great job hopping onto both culture trends and memes. They have established a humorous brand voice, which works very well for their target audience. #ContentChat pic.twitter.com/4XYpauwB1O
— Nex Gen Dynamics (@nexgendynamics) May 20, 2019
That’s interesting… since they produce pop culture, would you say that if they’re referring to their own shows that it’s just straight content marketing? Or is it considered a meme even in that case? #contentchat
— Maureen Jann (@SuperDeluxeMo) May 20, 2019
A2: Two that I can think of right now are @netflix and @DennysDiner #ContentChat
— Bernie Fussenegger #Digital360Chat (@B2the7) May 20, 2019
With the proper planning and thought, brands can find the right moment to join in on a popular trend without it feeling forced. The main thing is to know when it’s best to not engage (which we dive into in Q3).
A2a: I thought @UrbanDecay creating a limited edition #GameOfThrones makeup collection was smart marketing that connected with their audience. https://t.co/ZqakJy1b0M … #ContentChat
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
MAC cosmetics did something similar around Halloween a few years back with a line inspired by the “Rocky Horror Picture Show.” A2 #ContentChat
— Roselle Cronan (@MahoutMkt) May 20, 2019
A1 A2 We had a complex case involving a celebrity death (Prince), and we rebranded the logo. Talk about murky territory from a (literally) branding and issue-sensitivity. I wrote a whole article on this titled “Can Brands Mourn?”. Wild case. https://t.co/tP1SMSoxLe #contentchat pic.twitter.com/sdaYG7QdW0
— Carlos Abler (@Carlos_Abler) May 20, 2019
A2b: I really liked the Corvette ad that was in Prince’s memory. #ContentChat https://t.co/a4HUcgDsx0
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
A2.
👍🏽BarkBox
👍🏽Denny’s
👍🏽Our own Flex the FalconThey know
their audience &-their interests
-their tone
-their expectations
-their voice
-their needs& have carefully chosen
memes that align w/
that + their own:-purpose
-message
-goals
-vision
-voice#contentchat— Bentley University (@bentleyu) May 20, 2019
Wait, has no one said @Dictionarycom yet? They do a great job #contentchat
— Kristen Hicks (@atxcopywriter) May 20, 2019
Example from today #contentchat https://t.co/3836ZjANmk
— Kristen Hicks (@atxcopywriter) May 20, 2019
Q3: What are some examples of memes or pop culture events that brands really shouldn’t have gotten involved with? And what is the impact when a brand’s meme-jacking attempt goes wrong?
Many times, it’s not in a company’s best interest to jump on a trend. Again, it needs to align with your audience and brand identity.
A3
When it…
-feels forced
-doesn’t resonate w/ audience
-doesn’t align w/ brand values
-doesn’t align w/ your tone
-doesn’t align w/ your goals
-isn’t genuine/authentic
-isn’t a good time
-doesn’t have context
-is marketing towards a stereotypeit won’t work👎🏾#ContentChat
— Bentley University (@bentleyu) May 20, 2019
A3: not able to give a direct examp right now, but think about if your brand is monitored by legal compliance, or if you’re a healthcare system that needs to follow HIPPA—think about these before sharing a meme, as innocent as it could appear, it could go very wrong. #ContentChat https://t.co/tZZhazTsaJ
— Elizabeth M (@LizAshleyMedia) May 20, 2019
Poorly executed activities, especially those that make social statements, can result in extensive backlash.
A3: The Pepsi/cop/Kylie Jenner thing is the first one that jumped to mind. Anything that’s controversial and affects people’s lives in a big way is risky, and could even inspire boycotts #ContentChat
— Kristen Hicks (@atxcopywriter) May 20, 2019
There were hundreds, if not thousands, of people involved with that Pepsi ad, and not one of them raised an objection? That’s the really appalling thing. #ContentChat
— David Simanoff (@dsimanoff) May 20, 2019
A3. Shall we start with DiGiorno trying to hijack the #WhyIStayed hashtag to sell pizza? Pathetic, tone-deaf, and egregious. #ContentChat https://t.co/lrOFuNscoK
— David Simanoff (@dsimanoff) May 20, 2019
A3: I still cringe thinking about DiGiorno’s jumping into the domestic violence #WhyIStayed convo. #contentchat pic.twitter.com/6xVoFzjVvj
— Alan Fleming (@alan_fleming) May 20, 2019
A3: You know when a brand’s meme-jacking attempt goes wrong when either they receive immediate backlash, a decrease in engagement, and when their audience feels disconnected. #ContentChat pic.twitter.com/HXmPUx7TkO
— Nex Gen Dynamics (@nexgendynamics) May 20, 2019
Proceed with caution if you’re investing in something that is uncertain or unfinished. TV shows, movies and events may all sound great in theory, but the final product may be misaligned with what your brand intended.
A3a: I am pretty sure some of the brands that had hopped onto the #GameOfThrones meme bandwagon were having some cold feet after the backlash against the showrunners and season overall started happening. #ContentChat
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
A3b: When you add your brand to the conversation about an event or a trend that’s in progress, you have no idea how things are going to turn out. Which means you are also putting your brand at risk—by associating it with something that might conflict. #ContentChat
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
Q4: What are your guidelines or decision-making frameworks for deciding if a brand should or should not participate in trendjacking?
Start with your audience: will they understand the reference and respond positively?
A4b: I always start with: would our [persona 1] get this reference? Followed by, and would it give them a smile or a chuckle to see this from us? If both aren’t a yes, then it’s not the right fit. Even if we think the content fits an EE audience, for example #ContentChat https://t.co/4NEd9g4ibO
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
A4.
I think first you
have to understand
and define your:-voice/tone
-stakeholders
-goals
-messaging
-purpose/visionthen you have think strategically
about how each meme aligns w/ these elements + whether it will resonate/enhance your efforts.#ContentChat— Bentley University (@bentleyu) May 20, 2019
Does it align with your brand and the business you conduct?
A4: Brands should not attempt to participate in EVERY single trend if it’s not relevant. They should not try to stretch a connection between their brand and a trend unless it fits together naturally. It has to make sense for their audience and industry. #ContentChat
— Nex Gen Dynamics (@nexgendynamics) May 20, 2019
A4: Is there a relevant connection to your product? Is there someone involved who knows the topic you’re referencing well? Have you taken time to learn the full context? And did you come up with something genuinely useful or entertaining to do with it? #Contentchat
— Kristen Hicks (@atxcopywriter) May 20, 2019
A4: My first question would be how does this fit with the brand voice and how will our target audience accept and engage #ContentChat
— Bernie Fussenegger #Digital360Chat (@B2the7) May 20, 2019
A4: Guidelines for brands on whether or not to meme-jack:
* Do you have a connection?
* Is there any sensitivities?
* Will people get it?
* Is it brand aligned?If so:
Don’t bury the lead – show the connection#contentchat— Maureen Jann (@SuperDeluxeMo) May 20, 2019
A4: It it aligned with your brand’s overall goals and mission?
Is it appropriate for your brand to share or talk about the topic at hand?
Will it actually resonate with the interests of your audience? #ContentChat
— Express Writers | Your Content Writing Team (@ExpWriters) May 20, 2019
What do you hope to accomplish by jumping on this trend?
A4 Sorry I missed much of the conversation!
Question 1: What are you trying to achieve by jacking in on this thread?
Question 2: Does this line objective up with your strategy?
Question 3: If “no” to question 2, then why do you want to do this? #contentchat— Derek Pillie (@derekpillie) May 20, 2019
These questions need to be answered fast, and a diverse team can identify any issues faster than a homogeneous team.
A4. I think there’s no perfect framework for this. If you wait for something to go through multiple layers of approval, you’ll be late to the meme party. It’s vital that the people in social media can evaluate things quickly and understand the brand’s personality. #ContentChat https://t.co/0w1sirppSb
— David Simanoff (@dsimanoff) May 20, 2019
A4b. If your team moves quickly on memes, it’s ESSENTIAL for it to be diverse. Yes, that deserves to be in all caps. If you only have one point of view on your team, you’ll never truly understood how your message will be understood by a wide audience. #ContentChat https://t.co/0w1sirppSb
— David Simanoff (@dsimanoff) May 20, 2019
Q5: Let’s open the floor for other questions or thoughts on this topic.
Can a more “serious” brand use memes successfully? Yes, but it has to be relevant for the audience. This will depend on the timing, type of content and channel.
A5: My question for others is this – Do you think there are any exceptions for more “serious” brands to successfully use memes and to jump on trends? #ContentChat
— Nex Gen Dynamics (@nexgendynamics) May 20, 2019
A5: I think that you can be a serious brand and participate in pop culture trends or memes but only, as others have shared, if it is somehow relevant to and related to your brand and your audience. It has to be more than cool. #ContentChat
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
A5.
I think it depends on
how you utilize it too.The platform, the context, the timing, the longevity of the post, the follow-up, the CTA – that can influence it’s success. #ContentChat
— Bentley University (@bentleyu) May 20, 2019
Yes, utilization is key, along with analyzation. Brands should definitely analyze the results they get from participating in trends to see if it actually was successful for them. This helps them adjust their trend/meme strategy for next time. #ContentChat
— Nex Gen Dynamics (@nexgendynamics) May 20, 2019
Why do so many trendjacking attempts fail? Many brands try to be relevant by posting about a popular topic, instead of engaging with their audience on the topic.
Is the reason meme/trendjacking fails so often because the attempts are lame … or because people want to have actual conversations about the things they love, and brands just post and run, so they’re destined to fail? #contentchat
— Martin Lieberman (@martinlieberman) May 20, 2019
I think it’s the latter. It is often just an obvious ploy to get some hype versus an actual connection point. #ContentChat
— Erika Heald | Marketing Consultant (@SFerika) May 20, 2019
Again, this is why we need a mature cultural alchemy regarding trends, employee ambassadors, and influence. #ContentChat
— Carlos Abler (@Carlos_Abler) May 20, 2019
Agreed. Related: A credible connection and influence don’t come about from hitting retweet or like. But it can from replying and actually engaging with other people. #contentchat
— Martin Lieberman (@martinlieberman) May 20, 2019
Yep. When striving for authenticity, it’s helpful to…um…be authentic. Thing is, brands can’t be authentic, only people can. So the magic happens in a venn overlap of the typical guidelines, and the people. #ContentChat
— Carlos Abler (@Carlos_Abler) May 20, 2019
Which is why people need to stop thinking about B2B and B2C, and remember that social communication will always be person to person. #contentchat
— Martin Lieberman (@martinlieberman) May 20, 2019
I think meme-jacking is a lot like any other content. The question is this: Are you presenting a distinct point of view? If you’re just rehashing what other people have produced, it’s probably not worth the effort. #ContentChat
— David Simanoff (@dsimanoff) May 20, 2019
Leave a Reply